Direct-to-Device Satellite Connectivity: Why Decision Speed Matters

Direct-to-device (D2D) satellite connectivity is creating new competitive opportunities for wireless carriers and satellite operators in the United States. But as AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, and SpaceX position themselves in this market, another factor could prove just as important as technology: how quickly companies can make decisions.

Years ago, I spent a good part of my time working on a multi-carrier effort to build interoperable APIs. It wasn’t formally a joint venture. Call it a pre-JV. But it had all the ingredients: operators who competed fiercely every day, trying to build something together because none of them could do it alone.

Here’s what nobody tells you about these efforts: the technology is the easy part. Most of my job happened on the phone. I called member companies to make sure they’d show up to the next meeting. I negotiated what would go on the agenda and, just as often, what wouldn’t. Almost every conversation seemed to involve three lawyers, so even straightforward decisions took the long way around.

Trust was the constant challenge. These companies spent their days trying to win each other’s customers. Asking them to speak candidly in the same room was asking a lot.

There was also a pattern I learned to dread. At the working level, the people closest to the problem could often get real work done. Then a company officer would join the conversation, and the room would change. Positions hardened. Everyone started speaking for the record. And the lobbying never stopped. Companies would call me out of the blue to pitch their vision, hoping I’d put it on the agenda and advocate for it inside my own company. I wasn’t special. The same thing was happening all over the place. I’ve thought about that experience a lot since October 1.

What the AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon Direct-to-Device Joint Venture Fixes, and What It Doesn’t

On October 1, AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon finalized the direct-to-device (D2D) joint venture they first announced in May. Paul Roth, a longtime AT&T, Cingular, and Ameritech executive, will serve as interim CEO while the search for a permanent CEO gets underway. The JV will be managed by a board with representatives from each founding member.

Credit where it’s due: structure matters. A joint venture has a CEO, a board, and presumably a budget. Someone’s actual job is to move it forward. That’s a meaningful improvement over relying on a convener to spend the day working the phones and trying to get competing companies aligned.

But structure doesn’t eliminate the underlying tensions. It gives them a seat at the table.

The Board: Three Competitors, One Set of Decisions

Three companies that compete for the same postpaid wireless customers every day now share a boardroom. Every decision that benefits the JV also benefits two rivals. That creates a fundamental tension. Each carrier needs the venture to succeed, but each also has to consider how its competitors might benefit from the same decisions.

Existing Satellite Deals: Every Carrier Has Other Options

Each carrier’s existing satellite partnerships remain in place, and each can continue pursuing connectivity independently.

  • T-Mobile already sells satellite service through Starlink.
  • AT&T has its own satellite partnership with AST SpaceMobile.
  • Verizon has its own bets, including AST SpaceMobile, Skylo, and Amazon Leo.

Every partner has a reason to keep one hand on its own deal. The JV may create new opportunities, but it doesn’t erase the commercial interests each carrier already has.

The Softcard Precedent: Why Speed Matters in Joint Ventures

The last time these three carriers formed a joint venture, it was Isis, the mobile payments venture announced in 2010 and later renamed Softcard.

Apple Pay arrived in 2014. Softcard’s technology went to Google in early 2015. The carriers didn’t lack resources. What they lacked was the ability to move as quickly as a competitor operating with a more integrated product and decision-making structure. Apple could build and launch a unified product while the consortium was still working through its internal coordination.

To be fair, Roth also came up through Cingular, a joint venture that worked. JVs can succeed. They just don’t succeed by default.

SpaceX’s Direct-to-Device Strategy: No Meeting Required

Two days later, SpaceX moved again.

Five days after the JV was finalized, the FCC approved SpaceX’s 15,000-satellite direct-to-device constellation. The FCC also waived the rule that would have required SpaceX to lease spectrum from a terrestrial carrier. Two days later, SpaceX moved again.

On October 8, it announced a deal to buy Grain Management’s nationwide 800 MHz spectrum portfolio. The portfolio includes up to 14 MHz of low-band spectrum, a frequency range that most phones in people’s pockets already support.

The financial terms weren’t disclosed. The Wall Street Journal reported a value of about $8 billion. Carrier stocks sold off after hours, and European operators followed the next day.

Here’s the part I keep coming back to: until August, that spectrum belonged to T-Mobile. T-Mobile had agreed to sell it to Grain in March 2025 in exchange for cash and Grain’s 600 MHz licenses. At the time, it looked like a sensible cleanup of legacy Sprint spectrum.

Then the deal spent well over a year in regulatory review while the market changed underneath it. By the time the transaction closed, low-band spectrum had become exactly what satellite operators needed to reach phones indoors. About two months later, that spectrum was under contract with T-Mobile’s own satellite partner.

That’s not necessarily a story about a bad decision. It’s a story about a decision made at the speed of one market and finalized in a different market.

What SpaceX’s 800 MHz Spectrum Deal Actually Means

It’s important to keep the implications of the Grain deal in perspective.

  • 14 MHz isn’t much spectrum. The acquisition doesn’t automatically give SpaceX the capacity to replace existing terrestrial mobile networks.
  • Reliable indoor coverage in cities would still require towers on the ground. Satellite connectivity has technical and coverage limitations, even with low-band spectrum.
  • The deal needs FCC approval. The acquisition announcement doesn’t mean SpaceX can immediately begin operating on those frequencies.
  • Testing on the EchoStar bands will have to wait for a late-2027 close. The timing of the transaction and related spectrum arrangements matters.
  • The competitive threat is expected to emerge gradually. Morgan Stanley expects any impact on the carriers to appear over time, beginning in rural markets where terrestrial coverage is more spotty.

However, “gradual” isn’t the same as slow. In one week, SpaceX secured a constellation approval, the right to operate without a carrier partner, and the low-band piece it was missing. In the same week, the JV was seating its board and starting a CEO search. That’s not a criticism; it’s what joint ventures do in their first month. It’s also the point.

But “gradual” isn’t the same as slow. In one week, SpaceX secured approval for a satellite constellation, the ability to operate without a carrier partner, and a path to acquiring the low-band spectrum it was missing. In that same week, the JV was seating its board and beginning a CEO search.

That’s not a criticism. Those are normal steps for a joint venture in its first month. It’s also the point.

Who Gains Leverage in the Direct-to-Device Market?

The implications of this competition extend well beyond the three carriers that formed the JV. Different players stand to gain or lose depending on how the venture develops and how SpaceX chooses to compete.

Satellite Operators Other Than SpaceX

The JV is designed to give more satellite providers a path to U.S. wireless subscribers. Amazon, through its Globalstar deal, AST SpaceMobile, and other providers need the venture to function, and soon. But that opportunity depends on how quickly the JV can establish the commercial and operational arrangements needed to make it work.

T-Mobile

T-Mobile arguably has the most options. It has an established Starlink relationship and a seat on the JV board. It also has the most complicated internal position. And here’s my take: someone in Bellevue might be kicking themselves right now for not finding a way to hold on to that 800 MHz spectrum.

AT&T and Verizon

For AT&T and Verizon, the JV offers a way to pool spectrum and demand across several satellite partners rather than negotiating every deal individually. Pooling demand and resources can create greater negotiating leverage. Instead of approaching each provider independently, the carriers can potentially present a larger, more coordinated opportunity. A pooled hand is a stronger hand.

Spectrum Holders

Satellite connectivity is becoming another reason to want spectrum. The FCC has allowed satellite performance to count toward buildout requirements in recent deals. Its approach to spectrum allocation and direct-to-device use will also influence the opportunities available to satellite operators and spectrum holders.

Mobile Resellers and Rural Broadband Providers

This includes broadband providers that bundle mobile service to compete with cable companies. Whether satellite coverage eventually appears on a wholesale rate card will be decided by the JV board or by SpaceX if it chooses to sell directly. Either way, the decision will happen in rooms you’re not in.

What Direct-to-Device Satellite Connectivity Means for Rural Broadband Operators

This matters well beyond the big three.

For years, many rural operators made decisions slowly. To be fair, the environment allowed it. Competition was local and fairly predictable. Today, rural operators are dealing with national carriers selling fixed wireless, cable companies bundling mobile, and satellite operators that can make a decision on Monday and have it in front of the FCC by Friday.

The competitive environment is changing, and the time available to respond may be shrinking.

Most rural operators aren’t in a joint venture, but plenty govern like one. They have boards balancing multiple stakeholders, cultures built around consensus, and decisions that wait for the next meeting. Those are often real strengths, but they’re also a speed limit.

The AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon JV is worth watching as a live experiment. If three of the largest companies in the industry, with enormous resources and market influence, struggle to make decisions at the pace their competition sets, smaller operators should pay attention.

The lesson isn’t that rural operators should start making reckless decisions or abandon collaboration. It’s that decision speed is now part of your competitive position, and it deserves the same deliberate attention as your network, your capital plan, and your customer strategy.

So here’s my question: How long does it take your organization to make a decision that really matters? And is that faster or slower than the competitor you worry about most?

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Direct-to-Device Satellite Connectivity

What is direct-to-device (D2D) satellite connectivity?

Direct-to-device satellite connectivity allows compatible mobile devices, such as smartphones, to connect directly to satellites rather than relying exclusively on terrestrial cell towers. It can help extend connectivity into areas where traditional mobile network coverage is limited.

What is the AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon direct-to-device joint venture?

It is a joint venture established by AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon to develop a framework for expanding direct-to-device satellite connectivity for U.S. wireless subscribers. Its structure includes a board with representatives from each founding carrier and an executive leadership team.

How does SpaceX’s direct-to-device strategy differ from the carriers’ joint venture?

The carriers’ joint venture brings together three competing wireless operators to coordinate opportunities across satellite providers. SpaceX, meanwhile, is pursuing its own satellite infrastructure, regulatory approvals, and spectrum strategy. The two approaches illustrate different ways of competing in the direct-to-device market.

What does direct-to-device satellite connectivity mean for rural broadband operators?

Direct-to-device connectivity could introduce new coverage options and competitive dynamics for rural markets. It may also affect how wireless carriers, satellite providers, and broadband resellers develop partnerships and offer mobile services. Rural operators should pay attention to how these arrangements evolve because they could influence their competitive position.

Why is decision speed important in the satellite connectivity market?

The direct-to-device market involves multiple companies, regulatory processes, spectrum transactions, and partnerships. Organizations that can evaluate opportunities and make informed decisions efficiently may be better positioned to respond to changing market conditions. For rural operators, decision speed can become an important part of their competitive strategy.

Scroll to Top